Ideas & Inspiration

Tired of tripping over tools or paying monthly fees for off-site storage? When space runs out at home, the decision usually comes down to buying a DIY shed or renting a storage unit. While both provide extra room, only one truly pays off over time.

In this guide, we compare shed storage units vs. traditional rental units so you can decide which is the smarter, long-term investment for your home—and your wallet.

Let’s break down the pros and cons of each.

Pros & Cons of Building a Storage Shed at Home

Pros:

• One-time investment: Skip monthly rental fees. Buy once and own it forever. Many customers choose shed financing options like Affirm to spread out the cost
• Storage in your backyard: Need your snowblower or camping gear? Walk out back—no driving to a facility or dealing with access hours
• Adds value: A well-placed, well-designed shed can increase resale value and boost curb appeal
• Customizable: Choose from a variety of sizes, layouts, roof styles, and color finishes. Your shed, your rules
• Multi-functional: Beyond storage, sheds double as workshops, home gyms, or backyard office

Cons:

• Upfront cost: Higher initial cost than renting, but with long-term savings
• Assembly required: Our shed kits come with most materials included, excluding shingles and paint. You will only need basic tools and a weekend to put it together—or let us build your shed for you with our installed shed upgrade.

Renting a Storage Unit – Is It Worth It?

Pros:

• No building required: Ideal for immediate needs—just sign a lease and move your stuff in
• Climate control options: Some units regulate temperature and humidity to protect sensitive items like electronics, photos, or furniture
• Added security: Many facilities feature 24/7 video surveillance, keypad access, and locked gates

Cons:

• Ongoing rental fees: Monthly costs add up. And unlike a shed, you’ll never own the space. Limited access: Facility hours may restrict when you can grab your gear—no 24/7 backyard access here
• Zero return on investment: A storage unit doesn’t increase your home value or give you extra usable square footage
• No personalization: You get whatever space is available—no customization or creativity

Average Storage Unit Costs

Typical storage unit costs vary based on size, location, and features like climate control. Here’s a general breakdown of monthly rental prices in the U.S.:

Standard (Non-Climate Controlled) Storage Unit Costs:

• 5x5 ft: $40–$60/month
• 5x10 ft: $60–$90/month
• 10x10 ft: $90–$130/month
• 10x15 ft: $120–$180/month
• 10x20 ft: $150–$250/month
  
• 10x30 ft: $200–$300+/month

Climate-Controlled Storage Unit Costs:

• Add $20–$50 more per month, depending on unit size
• Ideal for electronics, furniture, photos, or anything sensitive to temperature or humidity

Other Factors That Affect Price:

• Location: Urban areas cost more than rural ones
• Facility type: Indoor vs. drive-up access
• Security features: Gated access, cameras, and alarms can increase the price
• Rental terms: Month-to-month rentals are flexible but might come at a premium

Example: A 10x10 climate-controlled unit might cost $150–$180/month—that's $1,800–$2,160 per year, every year you rent.

DIY Sheds and Storage Unit Comparison

Storage Unit Rent Vs Storage Shed Costs

The chart below highlights how monthly storage rental fees can add up over time, often reaching thousands of dollars without leading to ownership. On the other hand, financing a DIY shed provides a clear path to owning a dedicated storage space. With a typical payment plan, the shed can be fully paid off in about 20 months. After that, you no longer have monthly costs, and you gain a permanent, flexible structure in your backyard. Depending on your needs and how long you plan to store your items, this may be a more cost-effective and convenient option in the long run.

Source: clutter.com/blog/posts/how-much-do-storage-units-cost/

DIY Shed or Storage Unit – The Verdict

If you're looking for a long-term solution that adds value to your home and gives you 24/7 access to your items, building a DIY shed is the clear winner. While the initial cost is higher than renting an outdoor storage unit, you’ll own your shed outright and have a structure that works for more than just storage unit. On the other hand, a storage unit may work if you need a short-term fix or plan to store items you rarely need. But over time, those rental fees can surpass the cost of building a shed—and you’re left with nothing to show for it.

Buy a DIY Shed and Invest in Your Own Storage Space

Shed Liquidators DIY shed kits make it easy to build your own backyard storage space—designed for durability, functionality, and style. Browse our collection and find the perfect shed for your storage needs, with flexible sizes and custom features available.

Shop DIY Shed Kits Now >

We like to think of sheds as more than storage. Think of it as a home away from home!

FAQ - DIY Sheds Vs Storage Units

What’s the main advantage of a DIY shed over a storage unit?

A DIY shed is a one-time investment that adds value to your property and gives you convenient, on-site storage. Unlike storage units, you don’t have to pay ongoing rental fees or travel to access your belongings.

Are storage units ever a better choice?

Yes — if you need temporary storage for a short period (like during a move or renovation), a storage unit might be more practical. But for long-term storage needs, a shed is often more cost-effective.

How much can I expect to save by choosing a DIY shed?

Over time, quite a bit. Monthly rental fees for storage units can cost up to thousands of dollars, whereas a shed is typically a one-time purchase that pays for itself in a few years.

Is building a DIY shed hard?

No.  You don't have to take a master class in construction to build our sheds. Our DIY kits are pre-cut and include everything you need, except for paint and shingles. We also offer an optional built-on-site installation service for your convenience. 

Can a shed increase the value of my home?

Yes! A well-maintained shed can improve curb appeal and boost resale value, especially if it’s functional and attractive. Buyers love extra storage space.

What if I outgrow my shed?

You can always upgrade or repurpose your shed for a new function, like a workshop, hobby space, or garden room. It’s much more flexible than a rented unit. We suggest going one size larger than what you expect to compensate for obtaining more stuff as your family grows.

Are sheds weather-resistant and secure?

Absolutely. Our outdoor wood sheds are designed to withstand the elements. Our sheds are rated to withstand winds up to 115 m.p.h.

Have any questions?
Feel free to leave comments below! We would love to hear from the community.